I went with an XL, ready to return it. The fit is actually pretty good for me except the arms are oddly snug. I kept it, and have worn it without being uncomfortable tho. I went ahead and ordered a longer coat in XXL for days I need the extra length, and it fit a little looser but the arms and shoulders were still just a touch too tight to wear heavy sweaters underneath.I still like both the coats; this just is a consistent issue to tell folks about. If you have larger upper arms or shoulders, you may be disappointed.

Nothing to dislike